Hymn Queries
Questions written on a white card and handed to me at a recent Workshop (just like Press Corp. luncheons!):
How do you put on a Hymn Sing?
FOOD! It can be as small as a gathering at your home, so you can practice leading) or an ALL-DAY-SING-WITH-DINNER-ON-THE-GROUNDS. The gathering principle is the same. People come together on the model of the family, for mutual pleasure and sustenance.
Any suggestions for a small choir that sings a lot of unison?
First, good! Are you listening for pitch, rhythm, 'blend', phrasing, diction to make your unison an artistic whole, not a compromise? And second, is it always accompanied? Unaccompanied singing can be just beautiful, and should be a primary goal. As you move into two part, try rounds -- these make people sing independent parts and hold their own -- but all must know the melody very well before you start separating. As for two-part settings, they usually sound much better in equal voices, that is, with just women or just men. So perform them that way: let the men sit this one out, and then do a unison bit by themselves. Remember that your sound at the performance is the key -- no credit for attempting a difficult piece and not doing it well.!
Some people in my congregation resist any hymn that isn't an 'old favorite'. What do you say to them?
"Thank you for your suggestion! Name me five hymns right now that you want, and I'll start scheduling them next month." (Often they won't be able to name one on the spot.)...You will never be able to please everyone, and there will always be people who want to turn off their minds as they enter the service. So be polite to them and don't get worried at their critique. Imagine how it must have been in Bach's - or Watt's - or Wesley's congregations -- people expecting the new. "What's the newest hymn today?" (with great expectation) -- just like a popular song! Times change -- and we are not completely at their mercy. I like the middle position best -- cherish both the old and the new, and realize that hymns mean many different things to different people.
[Of course, none of this deals with leadership or choice of songs: that's another article!]
Table of Contents